Defeat may serve as well as victory
To shake the soul and let the glory out.
When the great oak is straining in the wind
The boughs drink in new beauty and the trunk
Sends down a deeper root on the windward side.
Only the soul that knows the mighty grief
Can know the mighty rapture. Sorrows come
To stretch out spaces in the heart of joy.
–Edwin Markham (1852-1940)
Mr. Markham–educator, author, and poet– gives us much to contemplate in just eight lines, beginning with the first seven words:
“Defeat may serve as well as victory.”
No, thank you, my spirit says. Defeat is humiliating, uncomfortable, and depressing.
Mr. Markham inspires a different perspective and a note-to-self: God may very well bring defeats into my life “to shake my soul and let the glory out.”
Reminds me of Jonah, the reluctant prophet who tried to run from God. The Lord told him to go east to Nineveh, an important city of Assyria. Instead he headed west, boarding a ship for Tarshish.
But a fierce storm churned the seas into a boil. In desperation to appease the gods, the sailors hurled Jonah overboard. Surely in those tense moments of near-drowning and then being swallowed by a great fish, Jonah felt crushing defeat. His life was over; it was just a matter of seconds.
Yet he didn’t die. Hour after hour in the utter blackness of the fish’s belly, he remained alive.
No doubt he felt shaken in his soul, and in his distress, he called to the Lord (2:1ff).
God heard his prayer and commanded the fish to vomit Jonah onto dry land.
Then the Lord repeated Jonah’s marching orders: “Go to the great city of Nineveh and proclaim to it the message I give you” (3:1).
This time Jonah obeyed, and the glory came forth. Jonah preached and the people repented. God had compassion upon the citizens of Nineveh, and did not bring destruction upon them.
What appeared to be a mortal defeat for Jonah turned into a glorious revival for a wicked city.
Read Mr. Markham’s poem again and you’ll discover more benefits of defeat, as outcomes of:
- Straining in the wind. Pressing on during adversity results in perseverance and strength of character.
- Drinking in new beauty. During times of distress we’re more aware of God’s glorious attributes at work in our spirits–attributes such as empowerment, faithfulness, peace, and grace.
- Sending down deep roots. Defeat often brings us to new depths of surrender and submission. It also brings us to new depths of God’s love (Ephesians 3:17).
- Experiencing grief. Only those that know a mighty grief can know the mighty rapture. Like diamonds against dark velvet, joy needs a backdrop of sadness in order to be appreciated fully.
- Experiencing sorrow. Sorrows create space for joy. Joy is never so sweet and overwhelming as after sorrow.
God knows what he’s doing, and he doesn’t waste time or effort. False starts and fruitless endeavors just don’t happen with our perfect Heavenly Father.
Therefore, when defeat comes into my life or yours, we can rest assured he is accomplishing his good purpose for us.
There will be victory in defeat.
Guaranteed.
(photo and art credits: www.zazzle.co.nz.com; http://www.searchforbibletruths.blogspot.com.)
Wow! I love this. Several things struck me right where God needed: ” Jonah obeyed, and the glory came forth”. So simple. Obey and glory will come forth. It’s about trusting Him in all things. Because, as you said, God definitely knows what He’s doing.
Thank you for such simple beauty. 🙂
You are most welcome, Heather. Amazing, isn’t it–GLORY out of obedience! God is SO good!
wow what a quote to ponder. I face booked it to share with others. Thanks for finding it Nancy. The last line resonated most with me. wow, space for joy. I think I need to copy this one and put it in my journal….
Thank you, Jean. I have to tell you: this poem found ME! It was in an old book of quotes and short poems from the 1920s that my husband found in his office. (We’re in the midst of sorting and organizing for our move.) “Victory in Defeat” resonated with me, too. So glad you liked it!
Thought-provoking poem! The idea of grief and rapture being interdependent is intriguing. I love when you said, “Joy needs a backdrop of sadness in order to be appreciated fully.” Beautiful!
Thank you, Rebeca. Markham’s poem does provoke thought! I’m delighted you found it meaningful also.
Victory in defeat…..it’s comforting to know that God can bring good from any situation. Even when we don’t understand the pain and defeat, we can always trust Him to strengthen and carry us through. I’ve missed having time to read yours and the other blogs I follow. It’s a blessing to catch up!
Thank you, Tresa. I agree: There is great comfort in knowing God will bring good from every situation! (Please remind me of that the next time a trial begins!!)
What a treasure of a book for Steve to find in the mundane task of sorting out an office! I had never heard of Edwin Markham…but, oh, what a wise man! Every line is pure gold. He obviously experienced what he had written in this poem. I’ll have to look into his history now! Great post, Nancy. Loved it!
Thank you, Cheri. So glad you found the poem to be rich with meaning!